Discover the Joy of Toasted Bread

Recipes for Toast-Worthy Loaves

Recently, someone asked me if I had a simple, everyday bread recipe for toast. I immediately thought of Old Order Amish Bread—a classic, no-fuss loaf perfect for new bakers. (You can find the recipe here.)

That conversation got me thinking: what makes bread ideal for toast? Is it the texture, the flavor, or the perfect balance of crust and crumb?

In this issue, we’re exploring three toast-worthy breads that highlight different characteristics—sourdough vs. yeast, freeform vs. loaf pan, and interesting inclusions like oats, cornmeal, and whole grains.

🌟Highlights:

  • A Slice of Wisdom

  • The Science of Toast

  • Featured Article: Exploring Toast-Worthy Bread

  • Quick Tips for Perfect Toast

  • Your Toast Challenge

A Slice of Wisdom

“Bread and water can so easily be toast and tea.”
– Anonymous

This saying is a gentle reminder of how small changes can elevate the everyday. A basic slice of bread becomes golden perfection with a little heat, and a humble cup of water transforms with the aroma of steeped tea leaves.

Similarly, experimenting with different types of bread for toast—rustic sourdough, textured cornmeal, or classic Pullman—can bring a new kind of joy to your table.

The Science of Toast

Have you ever stopped to wonder why toast is so satisfying? It’s more than just crispy bread—there’s a fascinating science behind the golden-brown crust, the perfect crunch, and the irresistible aroma.

1. Caramelization: The Golden Secret

When bread is toasted, the heat triggers caramelization, a process where natural sugars in the bread break down and form that delicious golden crust. This not only enhances the bread’s appearance but also deepens its flavor, adding subtle sweetness and complexity.

2. Crispness: A Matter of Moisture

Toasting removes moisture from the bread, especially near the surface. The evaporation leaves behind a dry, crisp layer that contrasts beautifully with the softer crumb inside. This balance is key to the perfect toast.

3. Aroma: The Toasty Temptation

That incredible smell? It’s thanks to the Maillard reaction—a chemical process that happens when heat meets proteins and sugars in the bread. This is what gives toast its nutty, rich aroma that fills your kitchen and makes your mouth water.

4. Toasting Smarts: Temperature Makes a Difference

Different types of bread toast in unique ways. Thicker slices need a lower heat to toast evenly without burning the edges, while thinner slices can handle higher temperatures. For enriched bread, the extra sugars may brown faster, so keep a close eye!

Featured Article: Exploring Toast-Worthy Bread

When it comes to making great toast, bread selection matters. A slice of toast can be hearty, subtly sweet, or nutty, depending on the loaf you use.

Here are three recipes that showcase how different elements—rising agents, shapes, and inclusions—can create a variety of flavors and textures:

1. Toasted Oats Bread

This sourdough loaf, made with einkorn flour and toasted oats, is a rustic, hearty option. The sourdough starter gives it a subtle tang, while the toasted oats provide a nutty richness and chewiness that makes every bite satisfying.

Sourdough Einkorn Toasted Oats Bread

Why it’s great for toast: The crust crisps beautifully in the toaster, while the crumb stays tender. The toasted oats add depth to both the flavor and texture, making this bread ideal for pairing with toppings that highlight its nuttiness.

Topping Ideas:

  • Sweet: Almond butter and a drizzle of honey.

  • Savory: Ricotta with a sprinkle of flaky salt and fresh thyme.

2. Sourdough Toasted Cornmeal Bread

This unique loaf combines the tang of sourdough with the crunch of toasted cornmeal. Baked in a loaf pan for easy slicing, it’s versatile enough for breakfast or hearty sandwiches. The cornmeal adds a rustic, slightly sweet texture that shines when toasted.

Sourdough Toasted Cornmeal Bread

Why it’s great for toast: The toasted cornmeal provides a delightful crunch, while the sourdough base brings depth and complexity. Its uniform slices make it perfect for spreads and layered toppings.

Topping Ideas:

  • Sweet: Honey butter or maple cream.

  • Savory: Mashed avocado with a dash of chili flakes and olive oil.

3. Light Wheat Pullman Bread

For a softer, more structured loaf, this Pullman bread is the ultimate choice. Made with a mix of white and whole wheat flour, its mild flavor and smooth crumb make it versatile. The Pullman pan’s lid creates a square loaf with perfectly even slices, ideal for toast.

Light Wheat Pullman Bread

Why it’s great for toast: The even slices brown consistently, and the soft crumb offers a tender texture that complements both sweet and savory spreads. Its mild flavor makes it a crowd-pleaser.

Topping Ideas:

  • Sweet: Cream cheese with a smear of raspberry jam.

  • Savory: Sliced tomatoes, a drizzle of olive oil, and a pinch of oregano.

Quick Tips for Perfect Toast

  • Use Day-Old Bread: Slightly stale bread often toasts more evenly and holds its structure better under toppings.

  • Cut Even Slices: Aim for ½-inch to ¾-inch thickness for consistent toasting.

  • Experiment with Toppings: Try both sweet (honey + ricotta) and savory (cream cheese + cucumber) combinations.

  • Store Bread Properly: Freeze slices for quick weekday toasting. Wrap individual slices in plastic wrap. Place in a zip-top bag, removing excess air. Separate slices with parchment paper to prevent sticking.

🍞Your Toast Challenge

Test this for yourself! Toast a slice of sourdough and a slice of Pullman (or other bread) side by side.

Pay attention to how they brown, crisp, and smell. Which one earns the title of "perfect toast" in your book?

Share your favorite toast creation on Instagram and tag @bread_experience! We’d love to hear about your toasting adventures.

Let’s toast to great bread!

Whether you’re baking for breakfast, snacks, or a fancy brunch, I hope these recipes inspire you to explore new toast flavors and techniques.

Happy Baking,
Cathy, Bread Experience